Middle Island NY FSBO Homes (135)

Sort By

We have 135 homes for sale by owner in Middle Island, NY. The median list price in Middle Island, NY is $161,030 and the average price per square foot is $9.

No Image
Homes For Sale

$639,000

  • 3 Bed
  • 3 Bath
  • 1,382 Sqft
  • 2.18 Acres(Lot)
90 E Bartlett Road, Middle Island, NY

3-bedroom, 2.5-bath home offers country living at its best. enjoy a cozy living room with fireplace, an eat-in... Read More

No Image
Homes For Sale

$849,000

  • 3 Bed
  • 3 Bath
  • 2,040 Sqft
  • 0.92 Acre(Lot)
6 Susan Lane, Middle Island, NY

Sprawling ranch in silver point, middle island this charming ranch-style home in the desirable silver point... Read More

No Image
Condo For Sale

$449,000

  • 2 Bed
  • 2 Bath
  • 1,568 Sqft
  • 0.0232 Acre(Lot)
891 Spring Lake Drive, Middle Island, NY

Welcome to 891 spring lake drive! this well appointed 2 bed/2 bath home is located in the amenity filled gated... Read More

Google Ads
No Image
Homes For Sale

$599,000

  • 3 Bed
  • 3 Bath
  • 1,944 Sqft
  • 0.52 Acre(Lot)
33 Summersweet Drive, Middle Island, NY

Charming colonial in the preserve – 3 bed, 2.5 bath, finished basement, and more! welcome to 33 summersweet... Read More

No Image
Homes For Sale

$199,900

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 675 Sqft
99 Whistler Court #99, Middle Island, NY

1 bedroom, full bath located in the development of lake pointe features 2 year young kitchen with quartz... Read More

No Image
Homes For Sale

$674,900

  • 4 Bed
  • 3 Bath
  • 2,102 Sqft
  • 0.25 Acre(Lot)
27 Devon Lane, Middle Island, NY

Situated on a spacious quarter acre lot in the heart of the wellington farms subdivision, this beautiful 4... Read More

No Image
Homes For Sale

$829,900

  • 4 Bed
  • 3 Bath
  • 2,278 Sqft
  • 0.918 Acre(Lot)
111 Currans Road, Middle Island, NY

New construction - center hall colonial with traditional and modern architecture throughout this beautiful home.... Read More

No Image
Condo For Sale

$424,999

  • 2 Bed
  • 3 Bath
  • 1,400 Sqft
  • 0.03 Acre(Lot)
259 Juniper Court, Middle Island, NY

This is the one you have been waiting for!! move right into this rare opportunity to own this townhouse! two... Read More

Google Ads
No Image
Homes For Sale

$175,000

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 700 Sqft
50 Bailey Court #50, Middle Island, NY

Welcome to hidden meadows and this quaint location! wonderful upper unit offers 700 sqft of living space.... Read More

No Image
Homes For Sale

$349,000

  • 3 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 953 Sqft
  • 0.23 Acre(Lot)
35 Dunbar Avenue, Middle Island, NY

Tons of curb appeal with this beautifully manicured property. this 3 bedroom ranch features a living room &... Read More

No Image
Vacant Land For Sale

$29,000

  • 2,396 Sqft
  • 0.66 Acre(Lot)
TBD Quinton Road, Brooksville, NY

Highly desirable picturesque residential building lot on a natural freshwater pond. build your sanctuary on the... Read More

No Image
Homes For Sale

$829,990

  • 5 Bed
  • 3 Bath
  • 2,500 Sqft
LOT 2 Currans Road, Middle Island, NY

Construction under way!! last lot left in the location!! 4 flag lots at the location!!!!! this to be built 5... Read More

No Image
Condo For Sale

$599,000

  • 4 Bed
  • 3 Bath
  • 2,600 Sqft
  • 0.15 Acre(Lot)
29 Perri Circle, Middle Island, NY

Stunning & elegant home with grand features step into luxury with this breathtaking home that leaves nothing to... Read More

Google Ads
No Image
Condo For Sale

$445,000

  • 3 Bed
  • 2 Bath
  • 1,100 Sqft
  • 0.08 Acre(Lot)
11 Westchester Court, Middle Island, NY

Nice 3 bedroom, 2 bath detached single family ranch in strathmore on the green homeowner's association... Read More

Pending
No Image
Condo For Sale

$420,000

  • 3 Bed
  • 3 Bath
  • 1,870 Sqft
39 Eric Drive #39, Middle Island, NY

Move right into this gorgeous 3 bedroom 2.5 bathroom malibu model townhouse with a garage in birchwood at spring... Read More

Pending
No Image
Homes For Sale

$549,999

  • 3 Bed
  • 2 Bath
  • 1,800 Sqft
  • 0.34 Acre(Lot)
25 Nottingham Drive, Middle Island, NY

Must see!!! step into this classic colonial-style home featuring 3 spacious bedrooms, 1 full bath with his and... Read More

Pending
No Image
Homes For Sale

$539,000

  • 3 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 1,029 Sqft
  • 0.3 Acre(Lot)
60 S Swezeytown Road, Middle Island, NY

Open house sunday 3/23/25 11:00-1:00. must see this charming ranch on a beautiful corner lot. totally... Read More

No Image
Homes For Sale

$270,000

  • 2 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 900 Sqft
87 Gauguin Ct. Ct #87, Middle Island, NY

Looking to downsize? mint 2 bedroom co-op refinished recently. private laundry in unit. stainless appliances,... Read More

Google Ads
No Image
Homes For Sale

$185,000

  • 1 Bed
  • 1 Bath
  • 700 Sqft
  • 0.23 Acre(Lot)
35 N Bailey Court #35, Middle Island, NY

Welcome home to this beautifully maintained, second floor co-op in the lovely hidden meadows community. open... Read More

No Image
Homes For Sale

$699,999

  • 4 Bed
  • 3 Bath
  • 1,464 Sqft
  • 0.16 Acre(Lot)
12 Lakeside Drive, Middle Island, NY

Exceptional lakefront property with endless possibilities discover a rare opportunity to own a private retreat... Read More