Bay Shore NY FSBO Homes (172)

Sort By

List
Map

We have 172 homes for sale by owner in Bay Shore, NY. The median list price in Bay Shore, NY is $915,161 and the average price per square foot is $380,312.

Homes For Sale

$735,000

4 Bed
4 Bath
1,000 Sqft

10 Muncey Road, Bay Shore, NY

Very nice house with lots of space, completely renovated, has heated floors, parking for 15 cars and connection... Read More

Homes For Sale

$625,888

4 Bed
2 Bath
2,034 Sqft

1454 Manor Lane, Bay Shore, NY

Mint condition hi ranch on 1/3rd of an acre - low taxes! hardwood floors, 4 bedrooms, 2 baths. unlimited... Read More

Homes For Sale

$769,000

3 Bed
2 Bath
2,200 Sqft

832 Hampshire Road, Bay Shore, NY

This spacious 8-room home has a 2-car garage, 2 full baths, a huge unfinished basement, a den with a fireplace,... Read More

Condo For Sale

$899,999

3 Bed
4 Bath
2,395 Sqft

29 Daniels Way, Bay Shore, NY

Stunning home in daniel’s way...discover your dream home in a sought-after 55+ community! this beautifully... Read More

Homes For Sale

$649,999

3 Bed
3 Bath
2,382 Sqft

1093 Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore, NY

Welcome to this stunning, fully updated ranch home in the heart of brightwaters. this property has recently been... Read More

Homes For Sale

$620,000

4 Bed
2 Bath
1,498 Sqft

1137 Reilly St St, Bay Shore, NY

Welcome to 1137 reilly st., a charming cape cod home in the heart of bay shore! this beautiful, maintained... Read More

Homes For Sale

$725,000

4 Bed
3 Bath
2,664 Sqft

225 Pleasant Drive, Bay Shore, NY

Welcome to this stunning 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath colonial home in the private community of mystic oaks in bayshore,... Read More

Homes For Sale

$599,000

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,503 Sqft

130 Smith Street, Bay Shore, NY

Welcome to this beautiful 3 bedroom, 2 bath colonial situated on a 100 x 100 property with a totally fenced... Read More

Homes For Sale

$625,000

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,290 Sqft

1079 Reilly Street, Bay Shore, NY

This beautifully expanded cape-style home offers over 1,200 square feet of living space and sits on a generous... Read More

Homes For Sale

$679,900

5 Bed
3 Bath
2,500 Sqft

326 Brook Avenue, Bay Shore, NY

Totally renovated from to bottom. beautiful mother & daughter colonial style home on quiet cul-de-sac. this... Read More

Homes For Sale

$595,444

3 Bed
3 Bath
1,234 Sqft

7 Mars Road, Bay Shore, NY

Discover this 1,234-square-foot ranch-style home situated on a peaceful dead-end street in bay shore. this... Read More

Pending

Condo For Sale

$659,000

3 Bed
3 Bath
2,178 Sqft

14 Pleasant Lane, Bay Shore, NY

3-bedroom, 2.5-bath gorgeous copper beach model with fantastic location! updated kitchen and baths! kitchen... Read More

Condo For Sale

$725,000

2 Bed
3 Bath
2,829 Sqft

43 Boathouse Lane, Bay Shore, NY

Welcome to this recently updated two-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bathroom townhome in the sought-after south... Read More

Condo For Sale

$949,000

4 Bed
3 Bath
1,508 Sqft

253 Helm Lane #253, Bay Shore, NY

An updated 4 bedroom, 2.5 bathroom atlantis unit with a prime location in the beautiful admiralty! the largest... Read More

Homes For Sale

$825,000

5 Bed
4 Bath
3,000 Sqft

80 Ocean Avenue, Bay Shore, NY

This is truly a piece of history waiting to be brought back to its original grandeur. a charming 3 story home... Read More

Homes For Sale

$539,999

4 Bed
2 Bath
6,098 Sqft

74 Belford Avenue, Bay Shore, NY

Pride in ownership! move in condition cape with hardwood floors, eat-in kitchen with new appliances and a... Read More

Homes For Sale

$559,000

3 Bed
2 Bath
1,190 Sqft

939 Thompson Drive, Bay Shore, NY

Short sale pending third party approval. needs tlc, seller has previously entered into a purchase option... Read More

Homes For Sale

$89,999

2 Bed
1 Bath

5 Birch Avenue, Bay Shore, NY

Welcome to this lovely 2-bedroom, 1-bath mobile home in a convenient & friendly community. the spacious living... Read More

Homes For Sale

$179,999

3 Bed
1 Bath

4 Birch Avenue, Bay Shore, NY

Discover the perfect blend of style and comfort in this newly renovated 3-bedroom, 1-bathroom mobile home in the... Read More

Homes For Sale

$279,990

1 Bed
1 Bath

74 Pinebrook Place Pl #74, Bay Shore, NY

Newbrook gardens, first floor 1 bedroom unit totally renovated, heat and gas included, 922 monthly maintenance... Read More

First
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
Last

Bay Shore - Statistics and Home Trends

Actives Activity Chart

Homes For Sale By Owner in Bay Shore 149

	Average Price
1 Bed Homes For Sale in Bay Shore (3)	$ 268,660
2 Bed Homes For Sale in Bay Shore (12)	$ 336,407
3 Bed Homes For Sale in Bay Shore (50)	$ 553,652
4 Bed Homes For Sale in Bay Shore (51)	$ 661,663
5+ Bed Homes For Sale in Bay Shore (33)	$ 841,152

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 532,307

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

128

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ 689

Condos For Sale By Owner in Bay Shore 16

	Average Price
2 Bed Condos For Sale in Bay Shore (3)	$ 675,000
3 Bed Condos For Sale in Bay Shore (7)	$ 868,855
4 Bed Condos For Sale in Bay Shore (6)	$ 922,667

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 641,007

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ 573

Townhomes For Sale By Owner in Bay Shore 2

	Average Price
2 Bed Townhomes For Sale in Bay Shore (1)	$ 379,000
3 Bed Townhomes For Sale in Bay Shore (1)	$ 469,900

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 597,696

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ 354

Land For Sale By Owner in Bay Shore 5

	Average Price
Land For Sale in Bay Shore (5)	$ 564,323

AVERAGE PRICE

$ 564,323

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

$ N/A

Statistics Bottom Ads 1

Learn More About Bay Shore, New York

Currently there are 149 homes for sale, 16 condos and apartments for sale, 5 vacant land for sale and 2 townhomes for sale in Bay Shore

Currently Bay Shore has 172 properties on the market for sale. The inventory was last updated 01/21/2025. Of these properties, 149 single family homes are for sale by their owners in Bay Shore, and 16 condos are for sale by their owners in Bay Shore. The average price of the single family homes for sale in Bay Shore, is $532,307, the average condo price in Bay Shore, is $641,007. The average price per square foot of the active inventory is $404. This is based the living area square footage.

Over the last year, there have been 0 of properties sold in Bay Shore. Of these properties, 0 single family homes have sold by their owners in Bay Shore, and 0 condos have sold by their owners in Bay Shore. The average sales price of the single family homes sold in Bay Shore, is $. Single family homes have been selling for per square foot of living area. The average sales price of the condos for sale in Bay Shore, is $. Condos have been selling for per square foot of living area.

The most active subdivisions with listings for sale in Bay Shore, are:

If you are thinking of selling your Bay Shore home, try our flat fee listing service, Our list fees start at $449, and may save you $15,000 in real estate commissions. Click here to start saving.

Disclaimer: Listing broker has attempted to offer accurate data, but buyers/lessees are advised to confirm all information IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use that it may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing, and that data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. The MLS may, at its discretion, require use of other disclaimers as necessary to protect Participants and/or the MLS from liability.
This data up-to-date as of 01/21/2025

Homes For Sale Byowner in Lawrenceburg (30)

Bay Shore NY FSBO Homes (172)

10 Muncey Road, Bay Shore, NY

1454 Manor Lane, Bay Shore, NY

832 Hampshire Road, Bay Shore, NY

29 Daniels Way, Bay Shore, NY

1093 Gardiner Drive, Bay Shore, NY

1137 Reilly St St, Bay Shore, NY

225 Pleasant Drive, Bay Shore, NY

130 Smith Street, Bay Shore, NY

1079 Reilly Street, Bay Shore, NY

326 Brook Avenue, Bay Shore, NY

7 Mars Road, Bay Shore, NY

14 Pleasant Lane, Bay Shore, NY

43 Boathouse Lane, Bay Shore, NY

253 Helm Lane #253, Bay Shore, NY

80 Ocean Avenue, Bay Shore, NY

74 Belford Avenue, Bay Shore, NY

939 Thompson Drive, Bay Shore, NY

5 Birch Avenue, Bay Shore, NY

4 Birch Avenue, Bay Shore, NY

74 Pinebrook Place Pl #74, Bay Shore, NY

Nearby Cities

Popular Cities

Nearby Counties

Property Types

Bay Shore - Statistics and Home Trends

Actives Activity Chart

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

AVERAGE PRICE

NEW LISTINGS THIS WEEK

PRICE PER SQUARE FOOT

Statistics Bottom Ads 1

Learn More About Bay Shore, New York

For Sale By Owner South Carolina

Statistics Bottom Ads 2

For Sale By Owner California

Statistics Bottom Ads 3

For Sale By Owner Maryland

For Sale By Owner Alabama

Statistics Bottom Ads 4

YouTube Video